So, without this sounding like a complete cop out, I'm at a crossroads...I've just finished my first chart D and I have a big decision to make. My gut tells me that I am not going to wear this knit. As much as I love it, I'm fairly certain that it is going to languish in my closet for eternity. It won't be large enough for a blanket in the light fingering yarn I chose, and it will be too large for a table covering if I complete the pattern as written. But right now, without doing chart D for the second time, I can still do the border and have a beautiful heirloom linen that I will use. Alot. If I weren't knitting with all of you, the decision would be easy and I would start my edging. I kind of feel like I'm cheating if I quit now, though, after encouraging the rest of you to knit along with us this year. Sigh. What to do what to do? I would love some input ~ have you all made circular shawls that you've worn before? Do you love them? I will gladly continue on if I hear great things. Any thoughts are welcome. For now, I'm going to set this aside and ponder. Ponder, ponder. And Tanna, if you read this, I'm so glad you stopped pondering ~ I would feel awful not making the full size if I had been able to convince you that you would love the circular shape.